Etsy or Your Own Website: Where Should You Sell?

Neither is better for everyone. Etsy brings you buyers who are already shopping and takes a cut of every sale for it. Your own website costs money whether you sell anything or not, but every customer it brings in stays yours. Plenty of makers end up running both.
This guide is for people selling physical things they make or source: candles, prints, knitwear, jewellery, cards, cakes for posting. If you sell a service, the same argument about directories is in our guide to Checkatrade against your own website.
Is it better to sell on Etsy or your own website?
It is better to start on Etsy if you don't yet know whether people will buy, and better to have your own website once most of your buyers find you without Etsy's help. The question underneath is where your buyers come from.
If strangers find you by searching Etsy, the fee buys you something real: customers you would never have reached. If your buyers mostly come from your Instagram, a craft fair or a friend's recommendation, and you then send them to Etsy to pay, you're paying a cut on customers you found yourself.
The trade-off is honest both ways. A website brings no buyers on its own. Being found on Google takes months of steady work, and a marketplace is a much quicker way to your first sale.
What does Etsy take from one sale?
At the time of writing, Etsy's fees for a UK seller include a listing fee, a transaction fee and a payment processing fee, all set out on its fees and payments policy. Fees change, so check that page on the day you decide.
Here is one worked example. A £24 candle with £3.50 delivery makes a £27.50 order. The assumptions: one listing, Etsy Payments, a UK seller, no Offsite Ads, and both percentages charged on the full order total.
| Fee | How it is worked out | On this order |
|---|---|---|
| Listing fee | 20 US cents per listing, charged whether or not it sells | about 15p |
| Transaction fee | 6.5% of the order total, delivery included | £1.79 |
| Payment processing | 4% plus 20p, assumed on the full £27.50 | £1.30 |
| Total kept by Etsy | Before any VAT on the fees, Offsite Ads or currency conversion | about £3.24 |
That is roughly 12p in every pound before anything else is added. Etsy also runs an advertising scheme called Offsite Ads, which charges a further percentage on sales it says it brought in, and VAT may be added to the fees if you aren't VAT registered. Both are on the same fees page. Put your own prices into the sum before trusting anyone else's, including ours.
What does your own website cost instead?
Your own website swaps a cut of each sale for fixed costs: building it, hosting it and keeping it up to date. You still pay card fees to whichever payment provider you use, so the saving is the marketplace's share, not every fee. Our guide to taking card payments on your website covers the options and what they charge.
That makes the sum simple to set up. Take what the marketplace kept from you over the last year, then set it against a year of website costs. If the marketplace's share is the bigger number, and your buyers already come from somewhere other than its search, your own site starts to make sense. If it is smaller, stay put for now.
For the wider picture of what a site costs to build and run, see how much a small business website costs.
Who owns the customer?
On a marketplace, the marketplace's rules decide what you can do with a buyer's details, whether you can email them later, and how your shop appears. Your reviews live on its pages, not yours. If it changes its fees or its rules, or suspends a shop, the sales stop with it.
On your own website, the order record, the mailing list (with the buyer's consent) and the reviews you collect are yours to keep and use within the law. That matters most for a seller with repeat customers: the person who bought a candle at Christmas is the person most likely to buy one for Mother's Day.
Do the selling rules change depending on where you sell?
No. Gov.uk's online and distance selling guidance says a customer buying at a distance can cancel up to 14 days after their order is delivered, without giving a reason. That right comes from how you sold, not from which website took the order. Our guide to what a small online seller must take back covers the exceptions, such as personalised items.
What does differ is who sees your sales. Under HMRC's reporting rules for digital platforms, a platform that connects sellers with customers may need to report UK sellers to HMRC. Sellers of goods paid 2,000 euros or less (about £1,700) for fewer than 30 sales in a year are excluded. Your own website does not file that report, but it doesn't change what you have to declare.
Which one suits your business?
Find the line that sounds most like you. If two do, the lower one usually matters more.
| If this sounds like you | Lean towards |
|---|---|
| You are testing whether anyone wants your product at all | A marketplace. No setup cost and buyers already searching |
| Most of your orders come from people who already know you, through Instagram, Facebook, fairs or word of mouth | Your own website. You are paying a per-sale cut on buyers you found yourself |
| You sell a handful of items a year as a hobby | A marketplace. A website's fixed costs are hard to justify on a few sales |
| You want to email past buyers, run your own offers or sell gift vouchers | Your own website, where those rules are yours to set |
| One shop closure or rule change would stop all your income | Both. Keep the marketplace but give yourself somewhere else to send people |
Can you sell on Etsy and your own website at once?
Yes, and for many makers that is the sensible middle route. Strangers find you on Etsy. The people who already know you, from your social pages, your stall or a previous order, get sent to your own site, where no cut is taken.
The one thing to sort before running both
Stock. A one-off piece listed in two places can sell twice in an afternoon. Either keep one-offs on a single site, or check both shops every time an order comes in, and say on each listing how long you take to confirm.
If you want to see what your own shop would look like before spending anything, that is what we do: we build your whole website for free, you look round it, and you only pay if you want to keep it, from £495 to set up and then from £69 a month. Our website costs and choices hub has the other decisions worth making first, or you can tell us about your business.
Frequently asked questions
Can I put my own website address in my Etsy shop?
Check Etsy's current seller policy before you do. Marketplaces set their own rules on linking away and on contacting buyers outside their messages, and those rules change. Your own social profiles and packaging inserts for orders taken elsewhere are yours to word as you like.
Will customers trust a small website as much as Etsy?
Not automatically. A marketplace lends you its checkout, its reviews and its buyer protection. Your own site has to earn that with clear prices, delivery costs shown before checkout, a real contact address, a returns policy and a payment page people recognise.
Your new website: Viewing
available.
Tell us your business name and town. We build your website and email you a private link to look around. Love it and it goes live. If not, you owe nothing.
£0 until you say yes