Christmas Returns Policy: What a Small Online Seller Must Accept

A ring of small sage grey gift boxes on a bone-cream ground, all facing one way round the circle, with one acid green box turned to face back the other way.

If you sell gifts from your own website, the law makes you accept a change-of-mind return within a fixed window after delivery. For most Christmas orders, that window has closed before anyone unwraps the present. Anything you take back in January beyond that is your choice. Faulty items are different and always come back.

This guide suits makers and small shops selling physical gifts online: candles, prints, knitwear, personalised decorations, hampers. It suits a service business less well, since cancelling a booked service follows its own rules, and it is a guide to what the gov.uk guidance says, not legal advice for your exact case.

What returns do you have to accept after Christmas?

For goods sold online, you have to accept a cancellation if the buyer tells you within 14 days of receiving the item, and refund it within 14 days of getting it back. That comes from gov.uk's guidance on accepting returns and giving refunds, which also gives the buyer another 14 days to send the item back once they've told you, and says you must refund the cost of standard delivery.

Count it out for a typical order. A present delivered to the buyer on 3 December has its 14 days run out around 17 December. By the time it's unwrapped on Christmas morning, there is usually no legal right left to send it back simply because it isn't wanted. What remains is the right to return something faulty, and anything extra you choose to offer.

One catch can stretch that window a long way. Gov.uk's guidance on online and distance selling for businesses says that if you don't tell a customer about their right to cancel, they can cancel at any time in the next 12 months. So the 14 days only protect you if your website says so before the order is placed.

Can the person who received the gift return it?

Not as a legal right. The gov.uk returns guidance says you only have to accept returns from the person who bought the item. The friend or relative who received it has no automatic claim on you of their own.

You can still choose to deal with the recipient directly, and many sellers do because it saves everyone a round of messages. If you do, decide what they get back. A refund normally goes to the card that paid, which is the buyer's, so an exchange or a credit note is often the more practical offer for a recipient. Whatever you pick, write it down.

What about personalised and made-to-order gifts?

Personalised and custom-made items are an exception to the change-of-mind rule, so you only have to take them back if they're faulty. The same gov.uk page lists personalised or custom-made items alongside perishable goods such as flowers, newspapers and magazines, unwrapped CDs, DVDs and software, and sealed items that can't be returned for health or hygiene reasons once opened.

What a buyer can send back, by kind of order
Kind of orderChange of mind return?Faulty return?
Standard stock sold online, such as a candle, a print or a mugYes. The buyer can cancel within 14 days of receiving it, then has another 14 days to send it backYes
Personalised or made to the customer's own spec, such as a name decorationNo, so long as you made it to their detailsYes
Perishable, such as flowers or a fresh cakeNoYes
Sealed for health or hygiene reasons and then opened, such as some cosmeticsNo, once the seal is brokenYes

Say you make decorations and sell two versions: a plain one from stock, and one with a name painted on. The plain one carries the 14-day right. The named one doesn't, because nobody else can use it. Say that on each product page, not only in the small print, so a buyer choosing between them knows before they pay.

Should you offer a longer Christmas returns window?

It depends on what you sell and how much a returned item costs you. Plenty of large retailers stretch their returns window over Christmas, but a small seller pays for every return in time and postage, so the honest trade-off looks like this:

  • For it. A buyer who isn't sure about a size or a colour is more likely to order if they know the recipient can swap it in January. It also answers the question before it lands in your inbox.
  • Against it. Every return is postage, packing and time, often in your quietest month, and a seasonal item that comes back in January may not sell again until next winter.
  • A middle path. Offer exchanges or a credit note rather than cash for returns past the legal window, or extend the window for standard stock only and keep personalised items out of it.

Whatever you choose, keep it short and stick to it. A promise on your website is the first thing a customer will quote back to you, and gov.uk is clear that it's illegal to restrict or take away the rights customers already have, so an extended window can only ever add to them.

What should your website say before the first Christmas order?

One clear paragraph on your delivery and returns page, with a line linking to it from each product page and the checkout. Here's a version you can copy and change to fit:

Christmas returns wording you can adapt

Buying a present? Unused items from orders placed between [start date] and 24 December can be returned or exchanged until [end date in January]. Personalised items can only be returned if they arrive faulty. You can still cancel any order within 14 days of delivery, and none of this affects your legal rights.

Fill in dates you can actually honour, and if you don't want a longer window at all, keep only the last two sentences. If you're still writing the rest of your terms, our guide to whether you need terms and conditions on your website covers what else belongs alongside this, and our guide to opening a Christmas order book covers cut-off dates and deposits for made-to-order work.

If your website hasn't got a clear returns page yet, the guides in your first website walk through what a small business site needs. Or ask us: ByRender builds your whole website for free, you look round it, and you only pay if you want to keep it, with setup from £495 and then from £69 a month. Our pricing page sets out what that covers.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to accept a return without a receipt?

Not necessarily a paper one. The gov.uk guidance says proof of purchase could be a sales receipt or other evidence, such as a bank statement or the packaging. For an order placed on your website, your own order record usually settles it.

Can I take a handling fee off the refund?

Not for a cancellation within the legal window. The gov.uk guidance says you can't deduct fees from the refund unless the item has been used or damaged. A longer Christmas window is your own offer, so set its conditions in writing before anyone orders, and keep them plain.

Does a longer Christmas window change what happens if something is faulty?

No. Faulty goods sit under separate rights that apply whatever your returns policy says. Gov.uk says you must repair or replace a faulty item returned within six months, and a customer can have up to six years to make a claim, or five in Scotland.

Your new website: Viewing
available.

Tell us your business name and town. We build your website and email you a private link to look around. Love it and it goes live. If not, you owe nothing.

Free. No card, no sales call.

£0 until you say yes