ASA Rules Four 'Carbon Neutral Delivery' Ads Misleading

A pale sage-grey line-drawn delivery van on a bone-cream ground, driving along a dotted road with a solid acid green leaf badge on its side and a blank outlined tag trailing behind it.

On 11 November the Advertising Standards Authority published four rulings against retailers whose ads said their deliveries were carbon neutral, or something close to it, without saying how. All four went against the advertiser. Three were paid Google search ads, for SportsShoes.com, the coffee seller Grind and the kitchenware shop ProCook. The fourth was a paid Meta ad for the toilet roll brand Who Gives A Crap.

The wording was short and ordinary: "Carbon Neutral Deliveries", "Carbon Neutral Delivery", "Carbon Positive Delivery" and "Carbon neutral shipping". The ASA didn't find the claims were false. Each retailer explained that the emissions from its deliveries were offset, through carbon credits or a removal scheme. The trouble was that the ads never said so. In the ProCook ruling, the ASA said an ad should make clear whether, and how far, a carbon neutral claim rests on actually cutting emissions or on offsetting.

The "not enough room" defence didn't work either. A Google search ad allows 270 characters, the ASA said, which is not so tight that the basis of the claim couldn't be stated. And in all four cases the page the ad sent people to didn't explain the claim. In the SportsShoes.com ruling, the retailer said the page that had explained it had been deleted.

Each ruling says it forms part of a wider piece of work on carbon neutral delivery claims. The ads were found through the ASA's own intelligence and its Active Ad Monitoring system, which it describes as using AI to search for online ads that might break the rules. The outcome in each case was that the ad must not appear again in the form investigated.

If you sell online and your ads or posts say your deliveries are carbon neutral, check where that line appears. If it rests on offsetting, say so next to the claim in plain words, and make sure the page the ad links to explains how it works. If you can't explain what the claim is based on, take it out until you can.

The same idea runs through our guide to what the advertising rules say about claims like 'best in town': whatever your marketing says, you should be able to show what it rests on, and the page a customer lands on should show it too. There's more on what your own website should and shouldn't say in our guides for small business owners.

The full guide: Can Your Website Say 'Best in Town'? What the Rules Say

Your new website: Viewing
available.

Tell us your business name and town. We build your website and email you a private link to look around. Love it and it goes live. If not, you owe nothing.

Free. No card, no sales call.

£0 until you say yes